Can Your Favorite Celebrities And Musicians Really Have Boundaries?

can celebrities have boundaries

This article was written by The Zillennial Zine’s senior fall editorial intern Lauren Sanchez. Find her on Instagram at @lauren.sanchezz. If you would like to share an article with The Zillennial, send us an email at thezillennialzine@gmail.com.

Life in the spotlight for celebrities and musicians seems to have perks — from traveling the world and getting paid to create any kind of art, to having millions of adoring fans supporting their work. Yet, despite all the glitz and glamour that comes with life in the limelight, there’s one luxury celebrities rarely get to enjoy — complete and utter privacy, a right most of us take for granted. Whether it is a tabloid dishing out on their dating life, a gossip influencer detailing the drama between two parties or social media speculation of who their latest song lyrics are about, everything a celebrity does is subject to tiresome scrutiny. 

Recently, singer-songwriter Chappell Roan and her incredibly fast rise to fame has led to another discussion about the boundaries of celebrities and their fans. With her standout performances at music festivals like Coachella and Lollapalooza drawing in crowds of over 100,000 people and opening for Olivia Rodrigo’s GUTS Tour, the “HOT TO GO!” and “Good Luck, Babe!” artist has skyrocketed to a level of fame that’s nothing short of meteoric. But with fame comes immense pressure and unwarranted harassment from so-called fans, stuff that Roan has taken to social media to voice her opinion and thoughts.

Falling in love with celebrities and the work that they create is something that is bound to happen for anyone who loves music, art, movies or any kind of media. For me, growing up obsessed with One Direction and proclaiming myself a part of “Stan Twitter” back in 2014 had me waking up every day before school checking on updates, news and anything related to the boys. Even now, I still consider myself a huge fangirl of so many different artists and it’s something I cherish — not just for the music, but for the communities I’ve become a part of.

However, the topics of “stan culture,” parasocial relationships and this idea of how these celebrities must owe something to their fans have created intense debate on whether or not celebrities are allowed to have boundaries and/or maintain a separation between their on-stage and off-stage personas. Can celebrities truly have boundaries despite putting their life in the public eye? Let’s dive into it!

What is “Stan Culture”?

If you’ve been on the internet for quite a while, more specifically X (formerly Twitter), you’ve likely come across groups like “Beliebers,” “Directioners,” “Swifties,” “Army,” “Arianators” (the list goes on and on) flooding your feed. These fanbases are global communities uniting fans from all over the world to support their favorite artists. Whether that support is driving up streams for a new album or mass-voting for their fave to win a VMA, these fans actively participate in what’s called “stan culture”. A casual fan and a dedicated stan are two very different types of people. According to Dictionary.com, stan culture is “the behavior or beliefs of an extreme fandom whose members fervently support their chosen celebrity or team, often reviling anyone or anything opposed to the object of their worship.”

@later.com

#stitch with @Peek so what is a Stan and where does the word come from? #glossary #socialmediatips #stan

♬ original sound – Later

While stan culture can be beneficial in uplifting emerging artists and helping celebrities receive well-deserved credit and accolades, it can also lead some who partake in stan culture to become perpetrators of stalking, harassment and complete invaders of privacy. 

For instance, pop singer-songwriter Madison Beer recently shared how fans would approach her for photos at the hotels she stayed in during her Spinnin’ Tour, prompting her to politely request fans on social media to refrain from asking.

In another incident reported by the BBC in April of this year, a “fan” of Harry Styles, was sentenced to 14 weeks imprisonment and given a restraining order lasting for 10 years after they sent the singer 8,000 handwritten cards to his London address. 

And as if that incident isn’t terrifying enough, another stalking case involving Grammy-hitmaker Billie Eilish put both her and her family at serious risk. After being sent hundreds of messages via social media containing love professions and violent threats against her family, and later experiencing multiple attempts of her stalker trying to break into her home, Eilish and her family were granted a five-year restraining order in 2023. Now in her most recent album, “HIT ME HARD AND SOFT,” there is speculation that her song “THE DINER”, where the lyrics dive into the psyche of a stalker, is a reference to her own stalker situation. 

While the definition of “stan culture” may sound intense, I do believe it downplays just how passionate and uplifting fandoms can be. Of course, that doesn’t mean there aren’t a few extremists in each fandom but I think labeling an entire community of people as “crazy” or “extreme” only serves to undermine that they can bring a positive impact across the entertainment industry. But unfortunately, extremists like those above, definitely work to ruin the relationships between artists and fans.

Parasocial Relationships — What Are They?

Parasocial relationships are often one-sided relationships that someone develops with a person they don’t really know in real life, or in this case, where a fan develops a deep and strong connection for an artist even though that artist is completely unaware of who that fan is. And social media contributes to this parasocial phenomenon heavily. 

When I was 13 and fully immersed in my One Direction phase, did I want to marry Harry Styles? Yes, without a doubt (and I still do)! But did I ever think this would be possible? Absolutely not! However, some fans can have an extremely difficult time differentiating reality from fantasy and can become extremely emotionally dependent on these celebrity figures. Just because you may know, on the surface level, everything about a certain celebrity — from the foods they like to their favorite books and even the names of their family members — it doesn’t mean you know them personally.

@fangirl.central

stop having parasocial relationships w celebrities ✋🏾 respect boundaries 🫡 be a fangirl of their art ❤️‍🔥 #celebrity #fandom #fangirl #podcast #popculture #parasocialrelationships

♬ original sound – fangirl central

Of course, there is nothing wrong with admiration and support from fans towards an artist and in return, that celebrity creating art, doing small pop-ups or even saying a simple “Thank you” to their followers, but a lot of these interactions between fan and artists often remain primarily transactional. 

Over the past few years, rapper and singer Doja Cat has been under flames by the media and her fanbase over the ways she treats her fans. Spending time on X and posting a series of now-deleted messages on Threads, the singer began creating online drama between her and her fans, even going as far as to say she doesn’t love them and to “get a job.” While what Doja Cat said was incredibly harsh, the response was in retaliation against the invasiveness her fans have created in her personal and dating life, highlighting that sometimes fans can overstep boundaries. 

Speaking of someone who has had every part of her life under the public’s microscope for decades, Taylor Swift has also been a major victim of harassment and stalking by others considered to be her fans. 

From having fans wait outside restaurants and recording studios to having people break into her NYC townhouse multiple times, Swift is no stranger to the intensity that comes from a fan’s obsession. 

Just last year, Swift’s co-collaborator and best friend Jack Antonoff had his wedding in New Jersey to which fans took the liberty of becoming wedding crashers and swarmed the outside of the restaurant where the rehearsal dinner was at. And if that isn’t completely absurd, some fans have created detailed spreadsheets dedicated to Swift and her boyfriend Travis Kelce’s work schedule and have even dubbed themselves as “personal assistants” for the couple. 

@jasperisoverheated

#greenscreenvideo like wdum u have a SPREADSHEET predicting when they will be together… the projection is REAL 😭 #fyp #taylorswift #traviskelce #taylorsversion

♬ original sound – jasper

I do believe that Swifties are some of the most dedicated and supportive people in the history of fandoms and internet culture. However, just because Swift helps us deal with our lives through her craft, it doesn’t give her fans or anyone the right to be so invasive into the inner workings of her life and her relationships. These kinds of parasocial relationships end up creating more harm than good and actually work to distance the relationship between an artist and their fans and reduce the connection to something purely superficial. 

So Can Celebrities Have Boundaries?

The short answer is yes — celebrities should 100% be given the right to their boundaries and privacy just like any other person. However, is it possible to establish a clear, definitive boundary between artist and fan? That’s complicated. 

@its_just_drama

They’re celebrities, not barbie dolls ppl keep up #chappellroan #weird

♬ Good Luck, Babe! – Chappell Roan

People oftentimes believe that celebrities and musicians owe it to their fans to be present and willing to interact simply because they are fans of them. But I think one thing people fail to realize is that no one is forcing them to listen to their song, watch their movie, buy their album or be a fan of said artist —  everything one does to support an artist is purely by choice and nothing else. 

While these celebrities exist for entertainment purposes, behind all the fame and accolades, celebrities are people too and should be treated as such. While stan culture, parasocial relationships and this fan feeling of entitlement can negatively impact the connections between an artist and their audience, realizing that celebrities have feelings and limits too — and that not every aspect of their lives needs to be in the spotlight — can help establish healthy boundaries. This shift can then allow everyone to refocus on what truly matters: the art and talent of these people. 

Do you think celebrities can have boundaries? How should we deal with stan culture and parasocial relationships between an artist and a fan? Let us know in the comments below!

More Pop Culture Articles

Relationship Articles

Beauty Articles

Leave a Reply

the zine for the in between

The Zillennial Zine is an online lifestyle magazine. We’re the zine for the in between, focused on keeping you updated on the weird, wacky & insane trends of the internet.

Let’s connect!